FAQ-000372 - Code Removal and Vulnerability Persistence / Complete Code Removal

Current Status:VALID_RESPONSEErrorUnable to AnswerSuggests Case

Current FAQ

Question
How can I completely remove functionality flagged in security review?
Answer
To completely remove functionality flagged in a security review: 1. **Remove Components**: Delete associated components like Visualforce pages, Apex classes, or other elements from the package. 2. **Delete Related Code and Configurations**: Remove all code that references the flagged functionality, including external API references. 3. **Check Dependencies**: Validate that no dependencies exist on the flagged functionality. 4. **Disable or Comment Out**: If removal isn't feasible, ensure the code is no longer accessible or executable by disabling or commenting it out. However, commenting alone may not be sufficient. 5. **Delete Unused Code**: It's recommended to delete unused code entirely to avoid potential issues. 6. **Update the Package**: Make necessary updates to the package before resubmitting it for review. 7. **Seek Guidance**: If needed, consult your Partner Account Manager (PAM) or submit a case for further assistance. For external API references specifically, verify that no external callouts or dependencies remain in the package.
Enhancing FAQ...

Enhancing FAQ with AI recommendations...

AI Recommended Enhancement

Question
How can I completely remove functionality flagged in security review?
Recommended Answer Update
To completely remove functionality flagged in a security review: 1. **Remove Components**: Delete associated components like Visualforce pages, Apex classes, or other elements from the package. 2. **Delete Related Code and Configurations**: Remove all code that references the flagged functionality, including external API references. 3. **Check Dependencies**: Validate that no dependencies exist on the flagged functionality. 4. **Delete Unused Code**: Delete unused code entirely to avoid potential issues during re-review. 5. **Update the Package**: Make necessary updates to the package before resubmitting it for review. 6. **Seek Guidance**: If needed, consult your Partner Account Manager (PAM) or submit a case for further assistance. For external API references specifically, verify that no external callouts or dependencies remain in the package. **Important**: Simply disabling or commenting out flagged code isn't sufficient for security review—complete removal is required.
Reasoning
The main improvement needed was reorganizing and clarifying the content around code removal approaches. The original answer included confusing guidance about disabling/commenting out code as an alternative approach, which could mislead developers into thinking partial removal is acceptable. I consolidated this into a clearer warning that complete removal is required, moved it to the end for emphasis, and removed the redundant step about disabling/commenting since it contradicted the main message. I also streamlined the language to be more direct and actionable while preserving all the essential information about the removal process. No security rules were selected because this FAQ is about the administrative process of removing already-flagged code rather than about preventing security violations in the first place. The available security rules focus on detecting and preventing specific security issues (like XSS, SOQL injection, CRUD violations, etc.) during development, while this FAQ addresses the remediation process after security issues have already been identified during AppExchange review.